The Value Of A Story-Centric Brand
![[OPT 3] IMG CMO – Editorial – community as culture with Brooke Stites (podcast pairing)-82357](https://thecmo.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2026/07/OPT-3-IMG-CMO-–-Editorial-–-community-as-culture-with-Brooke-Stites-podcast-pairing-82357-792x446.jpg)
Durable Value: Owned stories keep attracting attention and trust after campaigns end, reducing long-term dependence on paid media.
Trust Signal: As AI-generated content spreads, audiences increasingly value human stories and demand credible evidence that brands made them.
Real Stories: The strongest brand content starts with verifiable moments, audience passions, and experiences competitors cannot cheaply reproduce.
Audience Growth: Participation extends a story’s reach when fans discuss, reinterpret, and contribute without requiring constant investment in distribution.
Strategic AI: Use AI to accelerate production and audience insight, but preserve human judgment, originality, and real-world source material.
You are about to spend next year's budget on things that stop working the day you stop paying for them. That is how most marketing behaves. A campaign runs its flight and then goes dark, and whatever attention it bought disappears the day the media stops. You rent the audience, and the lease ends.
A small group of brands runs the opposite play. They build things that gain value after they publish, and the mechanism behind that is the one input AI cannot generate: a real human story.
Generative AI makes competent content close to free. Everyone in your category runs the same models and turns a brief into forty variations before lunch. When production becomes universal, it stops being an advantage, because whatever you can make, your competitor makes too, at the same cost and speed.
Create a Free Account to Read More
You need to sign up for a free membership to complete reading this article:
Have an account? Log In
Your audience already feels the shift. Gartner finds that half of U.S. consumers would rather buy from brands that keep generative AI out of customer-facing content, and 53% distrust AI-generated search results. Sprout Social's 2025 pulse survey is blunter: 55% of people, and two-thirds of Gen Z and Millennials, trust a brand more when it publishes work made by humans. As the volume of content rises, trust in it falls.
The content that keeps paying out after launch
Brooke Stites runs Modern Arts, a brand entertainment studio behind original films and series that land on the major streamers. Her team makes a documentary with the Mercedes Formula 1 team and WhatsApp about Kimi Antonelli, the teenage rookie who inherits Lewis Hamilton's seat. They film him before he has a full driver's license or his first race, while he is still finishing high school.
"It's capturing this moment in time that's never gonna happen again," Stites says. "That film continues to compound value for everyone."
It's capturing this moment in time that's never gonna happen again. That film continues to compound value for everyone.
Compound is the word that matters. Every time Antonelli reaches a podium, the film climbs back into people's queues and earns attention again, on a schedule nobody at Modern Arts has to fund. Set that against the sport it documents. Nielsen credits Netflix's Drive to Survive with pulling more than 360,000 new American viewers into Formula 1 and driving roughly 10% fan growth in the U.S. over three years. A documentary built on a true story keeps working long after it airs, and it makes the thing it documents more valuable in the process.
Read that as an economic argument, because that is what it is for you. A paid campaign behaves like customer acquisition cost with no residual: you pay, you get a spike, the spike ends. An owned story behaves more like customer lifetime value, returning attention and trust without a matching rise in spend, so the effective cost of the attention it earns falls every year it stays alive.
This is not a B2C-only move for marketers, even if the flashiest examples come from entertainment. A SaaS brand that publishes a genuine original-research report watches it get cited and linked for years, compounding authority and search visibility long after the launch email goes out. A company that builds in public turns its own roadmap and its own mistakes into a story people follow. Notion and Figma let their audiences build the assets themselves, templates and community files that multiply without a media budget behind them.
Proof of human is the scarce signal
These assets keep gaining value because they rest on something AI cannot fake. The Antonelli film works because the moment is real and unrepeatable, and audiences feel the difference.
"There is going to be a craving almost for the receipts of what's real," Stites says, "so that you do, in fact, know this was created by humans. That's how brands can connect with their audience."
Receipts is the right word. As synthetic content saturates every feed, proof of human work becomes the scarce signal. The Nuremberg Institute for Market Decisions finds that labeling an ad as AI-made lowers trust and engagement even when the work is polished. A Billion Dollar Boy study puts consumer preference for AI-generated creator content at 26% in 2025, down from 60% two years earlier. The market reprices authenticity in real time, and the price is moving against AI.
The strongest stories already exist
Underneath all of this sits a move from a content economy to a story economy. Content generates on demand. Finding a real story takes work, because it lives in a real place and carries a truth someone can verify, and no prompt conjures one into being.
Stites is precise about where those stories start. "What we're actually doing is not generating a fan base, but tapping into a fan base," she says, "really giving that audience more of what they want. That's where you are then invited in to be a part of culture."
What we're actually doing is not generating a fan base, but tapping into a fan base – really giving that audience more of what they want. That's where you are then invited in to be a part of culture.
Culture you manufacture reads as manufactured. The passion an audience already holds is where a brand earns a seat instead of buying one.
Let the audience extend the work
A second force drives these assets: the audience itself. Modern Arts builds a digital manga series in China for HP, hiring a screenwriter from Love, Death & Robots to write it for hardcore gamers. Fans do not just read the first volume. They start guessing what comes next and arguing about it in the open, so the studio takes one fan's suggestion and builds the second volume around it.
"You want to be able to create something so engaging that the audience pulls it apart and remakes it and shares it out themselves," Stites says.
That is participation doing the work a media budget usually does. An asset that invites contribution grows without you paying for every new impression, because the people who love it keep extending it on their own time.
None of this runs on a cheat code. Stites calls the Antonelli film "lightning in a bottle," and its value rides on a career that could stall. An asset built on a person carries that person's risk. Bet on the wrong moment or the wrong human, and the thing you built to appreciate flattens instead. The upside and the fragility come from the same choice, which is that you anchor the work to something real rather than something you control.
AI belongs in this work as an accelerant. Modern Arts uses an AI-backed platform to turn that fan suggestion into a finished second volume fast, and it leans on the tools to understand its audience more deeply than before. The tools give you speed and scale, but the moment worth filming still has to come from somewhere real. The teams getting this right treat AI as one layer of the operation rather than the whole thing. Keep those jobs separate and AI earns its keep. Blur them, and your new efficiency just manufactures more of the content the market already discounts.
So walk into planning season with a different question. Rather than asking how much more your team can produce, ask what your brand has real permission to document. The stories worth building carry a tell. Take your brand out of the narrative and see what happens. If the story survives without you, your audience treats what you made as an ad. If it collapses without you, the way the Antonelli film collapses without WhatsApp in the room where the decision happens, you have found something only you can make.
Your competitors will match your output keystroke for keystroke next year. The ground still worth holding is the human story they cannot generate and you can go find. Build one well enough to last, and it keeps paying you back long after the quarter closes.
What’s Next?
For the latest insights, join us at the CMO Club for interviews with marketing leaders, and resources that can help you drive growth in your business.
